Home Pro & Con Defenders Richard Falk, The Goldstone report and the battle for legitimacy, Electronic Intifada, 22/9/09
Richard Falk, The Goldstone report and the battle for legitimacy, Electronic Intifada, 22/9/09 Print E-mail

The Goldstone report and the battle for legitimacy
Richard Falk, The Electronic Intifada, 22 September 2009 




Despite the impeccable credentials of the commission members, and the worldwide reputation of Richard Goldstone as a person of integrity and political balance, as well as of being an eminent jurist, Israel refused cooperation from the outset. It did not even allow the UN undertaking to enter Israel or the Palestinian territories, forcing reliance on the Egyptian government to allow the UN mission entry to Gaza at the Rafah Crossing. As Israeli peace activist Uri Avnery has observed, however much Israel may attack the commission report as one-sided and unfair, the only plausible explanation of its refusal to cooperate with a UN fact-finding mission of this sort and seizing the opportunity to tell its side of the story was that it had nothing to tell that could hope to overcome the overwhelming evidence of the Israeli failure to carry out its attacks on Gaza last winter in accordance with the international law of war. No credible international commission could reach any set of conclusions other than those reached by the Goldstone report on the central allegations.



In substantive respects the Goldstone report adds nothing new. Its main contribution is to confirm widely reported and analyzed Israeli military practices during the Gaza war. There had been several reliable reports already issued, condemning Israel's tactics as violations of the laws of war and international humanitarian law, including by Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and a variety of respected Israeli and Palestinian human rights groups. Journalists and senior UN civil servants had reached similar conclusions. Perhaps, most damning of all the material available before the Goldstone report was the publication of a document entitled "Breaking the Silence," containing commentaries by 30 members of the Israeli army who had taken part in Operation Cast Lead (the Israeli official name for the Gaza war). These soldiers spoke movingly about the loose rules of engagement issued by their commanders that help explain why so little care was taken to avoid civilian casualties. The sense emerges from the testimony of these Israeli soldiers who were in no sense critical of Israel or even of the Gaza war as such, that Israeli policy emerged out of a combination of efforts "to teach the people of Gaza a lesson for their support of Hamas" and to keep Israeli military casualties as close to zero as possible even if meant massive death and destruction for innocent Palestinians.

Given this background of a prior international consensus on the unlawfulness of Operation Cast Lead, we must first wonder why this massive report of 575 pages has been greeted with such alarm by Israel and given so much attention in the world media. It added little to what was previously known. Arguably, it was more sensitive to Israel's contentions that Hamas was guilty of war crimes by firing rockets into its territory than earlier reports had been. And in many ways the Goldstone report endorses the misleading main line of the Israeli narrative by assuming that Israel was acting in self-defense against a terrorist adversary. The report does describe the success of the ceasefire with Hamas that had cut violence in southern Israel to very low levels, and attributes its disruption to Israel's attack on 4 November 2008, but nowhere does it make the inference that would seem to follow, that the Israeli attacks were an instance of the international crime of aggression. Instead, the report focuses its criticism on Israel's excessive and indiscriminate uses of force. It does this mainly by examining the evidence surrounding a series of incidents involving attacks on civilians and non-military targets. The report also draws attention to the unlawful blockade that has restricted the flow of food, fuel and medical supplies to subsistence levels in Gaza before, during and since Operation Cast Lead. Such a blockade is a flagrant instance of collective punishment, explicitly prohibited by Article 33 of the Fourth Geneva Convention setting forth the legal duties of an occupying power.

All along Israel had rejected international criticism of its conduct of military operations in the Gaza war, claiming that the Israeli army was the most moral fighting force on the face of the earth. The Israeli army conducted some nominal investigations of alleged unlawful behavior that consistently vindicated the military tactics relied upon and the top Israeli political leaders steadfastly promised to protect any Israeli military officer or political leader internationally accused of war crimes. In view of this extensive background of confirmed allegation and angry Israeli rejection, why has the Goldstone report been treated in Tel Aviv as a bombshell that is deeply threatening to Israel's stature as a sovereign state? Israeli President Shimon Peres called the report "a mockery of history" that "fails to distinguish the aggressor and a state exercising the right of self-defense," insisting that it "legitimizes terrorist activity, the pursuit of murder and death." More commonly Israel's zealous defenders condemned the report as one-sided, biased, reaching foregone conclusions, and emanating from the supposed bastion of anti-Israeli attitudes at the UN's Human Rights Council. This line of response to any criticism of Israel's behavior in occupied Palestine, especially if it comes from the UN or human rights non-governmental organizations, is to cry "foul play!" and avoid any real look at the substance of the charges. It is an example of what I call "the politics of deflection," attempting to shift the attention of an audience away from the message to the messenger. The more damning the criticism, the more ferocious the response. From this perspective, the Goldstone report obviously hit the bull's eye! Being willing to level such a harsh attack against a person as deeply sympathetic to Israel as Judge Goldstone indicates that no truth-teller will be exempted from vilification. 

Considered more carefully, there are some good reasons for Israel's panicked reaction to this damning report. First, it does come with the backing of an eminent international personality who cannot credibly be accused of anti-Israel bias, making it harder to deflect attention from the findings no matter how loud the screaming of foul play. Any fair reading of the report would show that it was balanced, took full and sensitive account of Israel's arguments relating to security, and indeed gave Israel the benefit of the doubt on some key issues. Secondly, the unsurprising findings are coupled with strong recommendations that do go well beyond previous reports. Two are likely causing the Israeli leadership great worry: the report recommends strongly that if Israel and Hamas do not themselves within six months engage in an investigation and follow-up action that meets international standards of objectivity with respect to these violations of the law of war, then the UN Security Council should be brought into the picture, being encouraged to consider referring the whole issue of Israeli and Hamas accountability to the prosecutor of the International Criminal Court in The Hague. Even if Israel is spared this indignity by the diplomatic muscle of the United States, and possibly some European governments, the negative public relations implications of a failure to abide by this report could be severe. 

Thirdly, whatever happens in the UN system, and at the Human Rights Council in Geneva, the weight of the report will be felt by world public opinion. Ever since the Gaza war the solidity of Jewish support for Israel has been fraying at the edges, and will likely now fray much further. More globally, a very robust boycott and divestment movement has been gaining momentum ever since the Gaza war, and the Goldstone report will clearly lend added support to such initiatives. There is a growing sense around the world that the only chance for the Palestinians to achieve some kind of just peace depends on shaping the outcome by way of the symbols of legitimacy, what I have called the legitimacy war. Increasingly, the Palestinians have been winning this second non-military war. Such a war fought on a global political battlefield is what eventually and unexpectedly undermined the apartheid regime in South Africa, and has become much more threatening to the Israeli sense of security than has armed Palestinian resistance. 

A fourth reason for Israeli worry stemming from the report, is the green light given to national courts throughout the world to enforce international criminal law against Israeli suspects should they travel abroad. Such suspects could be detained for prosecution or extradition in some third-party country. These Israelis could be charged with war crimes arising from their involvement in the Gaza war, convicted and sentenced to imprisonment. Such an eventuality is unlikely, but its mere prospect gives rise to deep concern. The report in this way encourages a somewhat controversial reliance on what is known among lawyers as universal jurisdiction, that is, the authority of courts in any country to detain for extradition or to prosecute individuals for violations of international criminal law regardless of where the alleged offenses took place. Universal jurisdiction has long been relied upon to apprehend pirates and their vessels.

Reaction in the Israeli media reveals that Israeli citizens are already anxious about being apprehended during foreign travel. As one law commentator put it in the Israeli press, "From now on, not only soldiers should be careful when they travel abroad, but also ministers and legal advisers." It is well to recall that Article 1 of the Geneva Conventions calls on states throughout the world "to respect and ensure respect" for international humanitarian law "in all circumstances." The efforts in 1998 of several European courts to prosecute Augusto Pinochet for crimes committed while he was head of state in Chile, are a reminder that national courts can be used to prosecute political and military leaders for crimes committed elsewhere than in the territory of the prosecuting state.

Of course, Israel will fight back. It has already launched a media and diplomatic blitz designed to portray the report as so one-sided and inaccurate as to be unworthy of serious attention. The US government has without explanation disappointingly endorsed this view, and apparently rejected the central recommendation in the Goldstone report that the Security Council be assigned the task of implementing its findings. The American ambassador to the UN, Susan Rice, evidently told a closed session of the Security Council on 16 September, just a day after the report was issued, that "[w]e have serious concerns about many recommendations in the report." Elaborating on this, Ambassador Rice indicated that the UN Human Rights Council, which has no implementing authority, is the only proper venue for any action to be taken on the basis of the report. The initial struggle will likely be whether to follow the recommendation of the report to have the Security Council seized of the issue so as to consider referring issues of individual accountability for war crimes to the International Criminal Court. Of course, such a referral could be blocked by a veto from the US or other permanent members, but even a discussion in the Security Council would be a severe setback for Israel.

There are reasons to applaud the forthrightness and comprehensiveness of the report, its care and scrupulous willingness to conclude that both Israel and Hamas seem responsible for behavior that appears to constitute war crimes, if not crimes against humanity. Although Israel has succeeded in having the issue of one-sidedness focus on fairness to Israel, there are also some reasons to insist that the report falls short of Palestinian hopes. For one thing, the report takes for granted, the dubious proposition that Israel was entitled to act against Gaza in self-defense, thereby excluding inquiry into whether crimes against the peace in the form of aggression had taken place by the launching of the attack. In this respect, although the report takes notice of the temporary ceasefire that had cut the rocket fire directed at Israel practically to zero in the months preceding the attacks, it seems to avoid drawing any legal conclusions as to the bearing of this context in which the Gaza war was initiated. The report also ignores Hamas' repeated efforts to extend the ceasefire indefinitely provided Israel lifted its unlawful blockade of Gaza. Israel disregarded this seemingly available diplomatic alternative to war to achieve security on its borders. Recourse to war, even if the facts were to justify self-defense, is according to international law, a last resort. By ignoring Israel's initiation of a one-sided war the Goldstone report implicitly accepts the dubious central premise of Operation Cast Lead, and avoids making a finding of aggression.

Also disappointing was the failure of the report to comment upon the Israeli denial of a refugee option to the civilian population trapped in the tiny, crowded combat zone that constitutes the Gaza Strip. Israel closed all crossings during the period of the Gaza war, allowing only Gaza residents with foreign passports to leave. It is rare in modern warfare that civilians are not given the option to become refugees. Although there is no specific provision of the laws of war requiring a state at war to allow civilians to leave the combat zone, it seems like an elementary humanitarian requirement, and should at least have been mentioned either as part of customary international law or as a gap in the law that should be filled. The importance of this issue is reinforced by many accounts of the widespread post-traumatic stress experienced by the civilians in Gaza, especially children, who comprise 53 percent of the population. One might also notice that the report accords considerable attention to the one Israeli soldier held prisoner by Hamas in Gaza, recommending his release on humanitarian grounds, while making only a very general recommendation that Israel release some of the thousands of Palestinians being held under conditions of harsh detention, suggesting that children especially should be released.

In the end, the Goldstone report is unlikely to break the inter-governmental refusal to challenge the Israeli blockade of Gaza or to induce the UN to challenge Israeli impunity in any meaningful way. Depending on back room diplomacy, the US may or may not be able to avoid playing a public role of shielding Israel from accountability for its behavior during the Gaza war or its continuing refusal to abide by international humanitarian law by lifting the blockade that continues to impinge daily upon the health of the entire population of Gaza. 

Despite these limitations, the report is an historic contribution to the Palestinian struggle for justice, an impeccable documentation of a crucial chapter in their victimization under occupation. Its impact will be felt most impressively on the growing civil society movement throughout the world to impose cultural, sporting and academic boycotts, as well as to discourage investment, trade and tourism with Israel. It may yet be the case that as in the anti-apartheid struggle the shift in the relation of forces in the Palestinian favor will occur not through diplomacy or as a result of armed resistance, but on the symbolic battlefield of legitimacy that has become global in scope, what might be described as the new political relevance of moral and legal globalization.

Richard Falk is the Special Rapporteur for the Palestinian Territories
Occupied since 1967 of the UN Human Rights Council, Professor of International Law Emeritus, Princeton University, and since 2002 Visiting Distinguished Professor, Global Studies, University of California at Santa Barbara.

 

Comments (93)
  • |2011-09-28 02:47:32 tera RMT 最安値  - tera RMT 最安値
    I am probably in the minority in my appreciation of summer thunderstorms. The sights, sounds and smell of a storm, in most cases, are a welcome occurrence in my view. The highlights include the tall stately thunderheads, especially in a late afternoon sky -- an awesome spectacle of color and form. The slow rumble of thunder and the nighttime fireworks are special as well. One of the first meteorological questions I posed to my father as a child involved my curiosity about the distant lightning shows at night, absent an accompanying thunderclap. I was informed that what I was witnessing was “heat lightning.” I don't know how this term was coined, but it suggests that heat lightning is in some manner different from the more common “window rattlers” that cause your dog to seek shelter in your lap. Now I know that lightning is lightning, but distance is the key. I will say that I have observed that the nighttime shows of “heat lightning” are not as TERA RMT//C9 RMT//GE RMT//FW RMT//ドラゴン...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-09-28 02:48:11 tera RMT 最安値  - tera RMT 最安値
    TERA RMT//C9 RMT//GE RMT//FW RMT//ドラゴンネスト RMT//tera rmt//tera RMT ban//tera RMT アカウント//tera RMT est//tera RMT sonic//SONIC RMT//アラド戦記 RMT//アラド rmt//アラド戦記 RMT//戦記 RMT//アラド RMT//arad RMT//arado RMT//tera RMT sonic//Tera rmt テラ //tera RMT 最安値
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-03 05:20:17 cheap uggs  - cheap uggs
    Welcome to purchase cheap uggs from us. We guarantee all ugg boots sale on our website, come in original condition and packaging. We still offer free shipping and fast delivery on all UGG Boots orders. uggs for cheap on all styles.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-03 07:12:20 ed hardy clothing  - ed hardy clothing
    Free shipping and fast delivery on all ED hardy orders. We sell all ED hardy products, such as ed hardy clothing, ed hardy clothes, ed hardy shoes. Additional, we guarantee the quality and price for every ED hardy product. Free shipping worldwide, welcome to purchase ed hardy.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-05 03:20:29 MBTshoes
    普通
    激安 パンプスに歩く速度ルブタン 靴とエクササイズウォクリスチャンルブタンーキングでは、歩く速度christian louboutinが違うよトリバーチ うにウォーキング方法によって呼吸激安 シャネルの仕方も違ってきます。体内シャネルに送られる酸素量シャネル 靴が多いほど、血液トリバーチハンドバッグの循環が良くなり多激安 グッチくの脂肪を燃やすことYves Saint Laurentができます。普通のウォーキングの場合4歩で1呼吸を意識
    UGG ブーツします。エクササmbt Namaイズウォーキング8歩で1呼吸を意識
    MBTします。エクササイズウォーキングのように、早い速度で歩く場合はより酸素を体内MBT Tatagaに取り込めるよう息を吸う時間
    MBT シューズ、吐く時間が長くなっていまMBT 通販す。但し、慣れないうちはMBT 激安「吸う、吸う、吐く、吐く」の4歩1呼吸MBT 新作がマスターできるよ
    MBTうに練習してみるとよいでしょう。 米国
    MBT シューズのコンピューターや電子部品業界から使われ始めたが例MBT シュとして汎用性のあるコンピュータをコンピュータ製造業者A（以下「業者A」）から購入した別のコンピュータ製造業者B（以下「業者B」）が
    mbt靴 激安 そこで独自の技術的（ハードウェアやソフトウェアなど）価値mbt 通販を付け加え独特のまたは特定（汎用の反対の意味）の機能を持つ製品
    ビブラムに造り上げ5 本 指 シューズ、業者Bは付加価値再販業者としてその製columbia シューズを市場に出した製造者
    UGG ブーツを指した。この様に文字通り、「オリジナリティーや独創性
    UGGのある製品化（装置化）を行う製造者（業者B）」として言葉OEMは使われた経緯がある。この時代のは文字通り「製造者」を意味し業者Aと業者 Bの間UGG アグに資本関係や委託製造、販売提携などの契約などはなくあくまで両者UGG クラシックの別個の企業行動であった。そして2006年現在、VTRの技術は完全に成熟した段階に達しており価格競争を通
    ugg 激安じて3つ目の市場が衰退する時期UGG ベイリーボタン1873を迎えている。この流れは
    ビブラムに留まらない。ラジカセ、ブラウン管テレビ、ポケット
    ビブラムファイブフィンガーズラジオ、電気ストーブコロンビア シューズ、...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-05 03:54:46 MBT Shoes  - ed hardy clothing
    MBT shoe is not a shoe, it is the smallest gym. Wholesale price on all MBT Shoes right now. Save up to 70%. MBT shoes can active your neglect muscle. Enjoy more benefits from MBT Shoes Sale and Discount MBT Shoes by cheap price. MBT Shoes Clearance on all styles right now, welcome to purchase cheap MBT to benefit a lot.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-08 09:04:43 MBTshoes
    With such things come the
    MBT inevitable letters from people who are leaving. "Goodbye, it's been nice working
    MBT Fora with you all, I'm retiring early and this is how you can contact me ..." that sort of thing
    MBT Shuguli Shoes. One of the things that killsMBT Tariki me, and I realize this happens much more often than in response to Goodbye emails, is how nobody seemsMBT Women shoes to understand the difference between Reply, and Reply All.Taking care of your teeth is important to keepMBT Men shoes a smile on your face without feeling that the world is staring at your
    MBT shoescrooked, discoloured teeth. While many children undergo orthodontic treatment by getting braces and other correctional devices for their teeth, adults are also seeing the benefit of fixing gaps, bridges and skewMBT Moja teeth.This brilliant breakthrough gaming console combines wireless, motion-activated play, web connectivity and educational gaming into a system
    MBT Karanithat plugs directly into...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-16 06:55:08 moncler jackets  - moncler jackets men
    The moncler outlet is located in the shanghai Mall in china and features a spacious selling area measuring 4.666 square feet on one floor. moncler coats offers a broad range of Bottega Veneta product, including men's and women's Moncler Jackets , small leather goods, handbags, luggage, eyewear, shoes, and Moncler Jackets For Women.The main entrance and windows of the boutique open onto the gallery of the mall and the interior design reflects the Moncler Vest For Men store concept.. China is seen variously as an ancient civilization extending over a large area in East Asia, a nation and/or a multinational entity.Ancient Moncler Coats For Women was one of the earliest centers of human civilization Moncler Kids . According to the 51-country Global Luxury Brands survey conducted by Moncler Coats For Men, one in three (31%) UAE consumers said they currently buy designer brands
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-18 08:38:26 Anonymous
    zcy Recall that like to buy an cheap Ugg boots is almost a year, this year, many things, have good and bad, real pressure let me a little breathless, face the people who face the false, I always turn a air jordan 5 blind eye to the people, I also don't go at heart, but sometimes ignore, really tired, so every time, what the unhappy things, I can wear my cheap Ugg, go for a walk. Looking at it, I can get many, cheap jerseys although a cheap Ugg not has a beautiful appearance, when i put it, i will have the beautiful mood, so as not to behave? Although I did not beautiful appearance, but at least I can not so hypocrisy,don't try to women handbags impress and change because of the crowd, to cater to taste, I am still won't change anything, I still who i am and cheap ugg also what it is, an original appearance, price is so cheap, appearance but also still UGGS Adirondack Boots ugly, or so comfortable. I think I was lucky, at least,I have an cheap Ugg, anytime, anywhere, and hav...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-22 03:21:01 feiduchen
    feiduchen
    we are a large pen manufacturers located No.786, xinchun road, fenshui Town, Tonglu city, Zhejiang province, we manage in all kinds of pen, including some environmental protection and energy saving pen, such as biodegradable pen. this pen is welcomed in oversea market, however this kind of pen didn't Open the domestic market, so most of our product are exported to abroad. retractable pen with gel ink is a totally new dimension in writing.
    ball penare writing instruments which use ball point writing mechanisms with water-based liquid or gelled ink, as opposed to the oil-based viscous inks found in ballpoint pen.

    Don't let others stop you from enjoying the films any longer, with the The Home cinema seating. Create your very own home theatre using these extremely comfortable and luxurious seats.
    school chairand airport chair are also the scope of our managment
    The three seater version is set up like your usual cinema seats with the central auditorium seatingsharing...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-22 03:27:36 feiduchen
    feiduchen
    we are a large pen manufacturers located No.786, xinchun road, fenshui Town, Tonglu city, Zhejiang province, we manage in all kinds of pen, including some environmental protection and energy saving pen, such as biodegradable pen. this pen is welcomed in oversea market, however this kind of pen didn't Open the domestic market, so most of our product are exported to abroad. retractable pen with gel ink is a totally new dimension in writing.
    ball penare writing instruments which use ball point writing mechanisms with water-based liquid or gelled ink, as opposed to the oil-based viscous inks found in ballpoint pen.

    Don't let others stop you from enjoying the films any longer, with the The Home cinema seating. Create your very own home theatre using these extremely comfortable and luxurious seats.
    school chairand airport chair are also the scope of our managment
    The three seater version is set up like your usual cinema seats with the central auditorium seatingsharing...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-26 06:44:37 feidudan
    we are online sneaker wears shop and managing in all kinds of international designer brand,such as nike and puma,including some small series like Zapatillas puma and calzoncillos calvin klein,houwever,the Zapatillas puma is much more famous than calzoncillos calvin klein in China,here is some information of puma shoes
    Puma shoes( Zapatillas puma) on sale new spirit among the emphasis is to convey people can exercise both elegant and dynamic, and this Puma mens speed cat in addition to the improvement in the appearance on the continued efforts, the promotion will also feature again, to bring people consumption who have the most complete sports fashion good choice.

    feidudan
    We use the same high quality glasses materials, but can offer them at a cheap prescription glasses because of our high volume, since we don't have the additional overhead constraints (such as retail rent space, behind-the-counter employees, and expensive displays) that your doctor's office or optical must ove...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-11-29 02:59:27 monclerlife
    September 1991 25 Japanese Supreme Court today rejected rock hand county council, Moncler jackets county authorities, especially GeLiao government appeal verdict formal visits to the yasukuni shrine violates the moncler coats 2010 constitution. Japan’s Supreme Court decision to confirm the higher court sendai 10th January 1991 regarding visits to the yasukuni shrine violates the constitution. moncler sale High court of rock sendai hand county residents of the yasukuni shrine litigation trial. Action that rock hand county council in 1979 to achieve the requirements as the emperor, Moncler the prime minister official visits to the yasukuni shrine’s resolution and speaker, county aid in 1981 as 35 people pay visits to the yasukuni shrine at public expense of incense money violates the constitution about the principle of separation of and requirements of more than 20,000 yen to recover the temple.for money. Moncler jackets sale The trial, the higher court that sendai forma...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-02 03:43:30 feiduchang
    Some work requires Discount mbt shoes Shoes On Sale you to stand or walk change that can be very painful your legs, ankle, abercrombiethe back, neck, and more. It can be very painful, in your feet, long time in a time of the best shoes need long time work, is a new kind of discountmbt walking shoes shoes these shoes are in order to relieve pain to stand for long. They are specially for those on the foot of all time, you will find that you don’t hurt or pain, when you start your Zuri cheap mbt shoeswomen used to wear black shoes.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-02 03:45:11 feiduchang
    Giuseppe zanotti Shoes is a very famous brand in the international footwear industry , because of the high-quality, heavy details, lead the trend of famous and unique design.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-06 07:55:42 monclerlife

    French unions 23 launched a nationwide strike in the second month, Moncler jackets 290 million people took to the streets to protest against the government intends to push the retirement system reform. Because of air moncler coats transport operators are also involved in Paris Charles DE gaulle airport, moncler sale estimation and ollie airport yesterday 40% and 50% of the flights are cancelled, other airport also can maintain 60% flights. Moncler Union estimated 2.5 million in December 7, is expected to strike the number 23 strike than last time, France has a protest rally, traffic 231, more than half the train service, Moncler jackets sale but the connection of Britain and France eurostar service, maintain the normal. The BBC reports, the big strike over to Paris public transportation. Paris metro line, there are 16 during the morning go to work in the 23rd, Moncler jackets Men ?Paris metro only five runs normally. From the game, inter are not a real sense of team....
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-08 09:09:38 Louis Vttion handbags  - Louis Vttion handbags
    The Epi Leather, shiny palladium hardware, rolled leather handles with ring attachments, and Louis Vuitton Canvas engraved padlock on the side of the bag make this handbag truly standout. Instantly, I fell in love with the balenciaga bags Speedy in black! It was gorgeous, sophisticated and I thought it would lovely in my collection. I absolutely loved the Speedy Cube, but due to the ultra high price I turned to the Epi collection for a more affordable take on a black louis vuitton belts handbag. At the moment, I have four different louis vuitton clutches in my collection going on a 5th in two weeks and I thought it was quite senseless to even think to getting lousi vuitton Speedy 30. So I change to search for a black Jimmy Choo clutches I came across the Louis Vuitton Leather Lockit and it was love at first sight! I have been eager to own a Louis Vuitton store Outlet in black for some time now. If the Catier bags doesnt interest you in black, it also is available in C...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-09 06:44:31 moncler ladies  - http://www.monclertoyou.com/new-arrivals/
    xiaolaba Success is sometimes imaginary so difficult, everyday to develop a good habit to moncler jackets, and stick to it, maybe success are assured. Every day to develop a
    good habit to moncler vests is very easy, hard to persevere
    of moncler kids. This is the combination
    of faith and perseverance, so successful people so little, it is not surprising moncler kids jackets."A man to have great achievement of moncler for kids, must everyday some small achievement." Rich and poor just money difference betwin moncler mens jackets . Here is a small story: a rich man to the poor cow, poor hope began to struggle with moncler ladies jacket. But cow to graze, should have a meal, days sad. The poor and the ox to sell moncler ladies coats, bought a few sheep, eating a, and the rest in afterlife lamb. But the lamb born hesitated moncler ladies vest, days and difficult. The poor took sheep and sold buy became chicken moncler womens vest, want to let chicken eggs make mon...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-14 07:48:49 links of london  - links of london
    links of london
    Links Jewellery
    links of london sale
    links of london for sale
    links of london uk
    links of london whoesale
    Bangles
    Bracelets
    Charms
    Earrings
    Necklaces
    Rings
    Watches
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-14 08:45:36 Anonymous
    It is not possible to consider moncler the calendar to buy two different moncler sale types of cheap moncler winter coat ? In fact, only two discount moncler useless expenditure, you have found in the Horton buy moncler ski jackets, this is very interesting, fashion-conscious and functional. No matter where you are, Horton Knights moncler usa work. Can ski, because they are broken moncler womens , is very attractive. Cute, moncler womens sale but also attractive. Put them together, you have this awesome cheap moncler women jackets.This moncler mens men, may need a warm temperature, light weight, easy to navigate. His moncler men sale shoes so now covered slope indicators.Young girls back to juicy quilted cheap moncler mens handbag. Small, white, blue and pink, white, standard color number, and with all your wardrobe together. This is your choice moncler jackets whether to use this style sheet, or you just want to add only one moncler coat . My child is very difficult to believe that...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2010-12-28 02:34:34 Puma sale  - http://www.pumasportshs.com
    xyyPuma shoes has become the fastest growing sports brand. The answer just is go into Puma Outlet, and here you can discover variety of cheap puma shoes, and buy one pair of health Puma Speed Cat for yourself or your good friends. We will provide high quality and smile service. Our Puma store has been put the new design in the fashion design and living area with shoes, and PUMA Drift Cat is one of Mens Puma Drift Cat the world leading sport lifestyle companies that designs and Womens puma running shoes develops footwear, apparel and accessories. Puma online in sport and ends in Fashion. Plus on these stores, you will discover a great deal of great Nike puma shoes on the many styles of PUMA Shoes for Men.
    You can select puma sneakers in bold mixture of colors, peerless and high quality sneaker fashioned with high-gloss overlays in different style and size. To end with, Puma shoes 2010 have that timbre to satisfy your every need. The variety is so huge, PUMA Shoes for Men can be t...
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-01-06 06:16:13 timberland boots  - http://www.timberland-online.net
    The timberland boots company commitment is to outstanding creation, the design gives the world's most innovative products. This was founded in 1918, Boston, USA company startup cheap timberland boots is a professional shoe-making company. In the 1960s, they adopt unique shoe-making technology to produce the world first pair of timberland 6 inch boots and vamp without suture shoes, shoe bottom and the upper completely casting close, produced a real sense of waterproof shoes.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-01-27 09:30:33 sdf  - dsfsdf
    mbt shoes that calls for its inspiration from unstable surfaces is bound to provide some extremely basic benefits. Wearers can anticipate to know-how an enlargement within an amazing provide of distinctive functions,cheap mbt shoes including: enhanced posture, toned, shaped body,mbt anti shoes activation of routinely neglected muscles. In short, MBT touts its shoe receiving a complete method activator,mbt shoes sale merely just one that stimulates the muscle tissues and run outs them merely by utilizing the organically grown movement of mbt walking shoes. MBT sneaker even states that wellness solution physicians typically advise the shoe to help alleviate the pains linked to particular injuries.mbt clearance shoes typically appear for wellbeing practitioner preceding to making any modifications using the regimen.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-01-31 06:07:30 nike air max  - nike air max
    Please do not hesitate,order nike air max 90 on our online store,and you will get a big discount!
    How much everybody love nike air max 2011 and what cheap price you are willing to pay for them!
    We have collected a large quantity of nike air max 180 which are popular and people are favor of them.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-02-14 06:22:50 cheap NFL jerseys  - discount jerseys
    NFL is the best league loved by most people in the world.Whether you are seeking Cheap NFL Jerseys,superior NFL Jerseys sale or any other kinds of Discount jerseys,our shop has them in all styles and sizes.NBA fans can find the ultimate selection of Wholesale NBA Jerseys for your favorite team here.we provide MLB Jerseys and low price Soccer Jerseys as well.The NHL Jerseys are made with quick-drying nylon mesh and designed with player name,number and team graphics sewn on.Buy cheap wholesale Jerseys with 100% satisfied quality from our shop now.

    A pair of Cheap GHD Hair Straighteners is suit for women who pursue beautiful salon-perfect hair.You can find GHD Hair Straighteners sale in a variety of different styles and colours in our shop,includes GHD IV Styler,the GHD Limited Edition,New GHD Midnight Collection and so on.they have won awards across the board for the quality and performance of their products.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-02-28 09:28:14 Five Fingers shoes  - Five Fingers shoes
    Pat White ran a 4.55 40-yard dash time at his NFL Combine, had a track record of Five Fingers shoes success and accuracy in college behind him — and was regarded as a poor selection even before he washed out with the Dolphins.Many are the stories of Vibram Five Finger the workout warrior who wins the Combine before failing to produce in the NFL.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-03-01 02:27:16 vibram five fingers speed  - http://www.onfingershoes.com/vibram-five-fingers-s
    Qin 110301
    We planned our weddings vibram five finger shoes with the help of Barbie dolls and the tiny purple wild flowers growing in our side yard. We became scientists and tested concoctions of milk, orange juice, and mouthwash. We ate handfuls of vibram fivefingers kso bittersweet chocolate chips and licked peanut butter off spoons. When we ran out of sweets to eat, we snitched sugary Flintstones vitamins out of the vibram kso trek medicine cabinet. We became masters of the Kraft macaroni and cheese lunch, and we dutifully called our mother at work three times a day to give her updates on our vibram five fingers sprint adventures. But don't call too often or speak too loudly or whine too much, we told ourselves, or else they'll get annoyed and she'll get fired and the vibram five fingers classic summers will end.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-03-08 08:13:12 Five Fingers shoes  - Five Fingers shoes
    Internet pranksters are back in action. A week ago, Jim Carrey was Five Fingers shoes reportedly dead by the Internet. Now, another comedy actor becomes a victim of Internet pranksters. A story tells about Adam Sandler’s death has been Vibram Five Finger circulated today.Adam Sandler was reportedly dead in a snowboard accident, said the Internet pranksters.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-03-09 10:19:26 replica handbags  - replica handbags


    Designer Handbags,coach hobos flaps including Louis Vuitton Handbags we provide in our replica handbags online store are 100% coach originals satisfaction guaranteed. You will find a large selection of replica LV Handbags in coach satchels carryalls fine details! Help yourself to take a look at our top sales of luxury handbags! Wish you a wonderful shopping time on www.bestlvhandbags.com!
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-04-29 03:24:10 coach handbags wholesale  - cheap handbags
    This is a great post. you got cheap handbags online .I like cheap designer handbags as well give you designer handbags outlet
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-01 07:32:50 tiffany setting
    Please remember that vintage watches have survived for many decades by being treated Romance God created the brand since 1988,

    replica watchesthe company, registered in 102 countries around the world omega seamaster ladies

    watches,jewelry brand,watches onlinemerchandise exports to 70 countries, is a specialized manufacturer

    of watches and jewelry. Romance of God in 1998 to become a global brand, replica rolex
    hire famous Swiss designer Wolfgang Jonsson program development of brand identity company logos,tiffany jewelry

    uniform color. Romance God omega seamaster quartz watches Korea Co.,Tiffany Ltd. has become the leading

    companies in the industry, rings onlinethe reputation is well known South Korean brand abroad. God watches Co.

    Tiffany ringsLtd. has always been committed to technological innovation and excellence in quality romantic

    and fashion capture,jewellery shopfashion jewelry has become a world dedicated to business goals and

    tireless efforts.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-02 03:36:01 Anonymous  - coach factory outlet
    coach factory outlet can design new and original products that are also functional. The stylish appearance of products, sophisticated workmanship, superior quality and highly competitive prices have won the customer's trust and love from consumers at home and abroad. So you can rest assured that purchase.coach factory outlet online is one of the four playable survivors in Left 4 Dead 2. He was a high school health teacher and coordinator for the freshman football team before the Infection hit his hometown of Savannah.A combination of effort and newest technology,The coach factory store is always maintaining high quality standard for every coach designer bags to satisfy its customers.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-02 03:38:21 Anonymous  - coach factory online
    coach factory online even provides special discounts for VIP members. The vacancies of register are limited. So do it as quickly as possible.coach factory outlet offer excellent, elegant coach products in order to generate room for your new collections.They're purchased more quickly that you may at any time imagine.coach factory outlet online is one of the four playable survivors in Left 4 Dead 2. He was a high school health teacher and coordinator for the freshman football team before the Infection hit his hometown of Savannah.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-02 03:40:09 Anonymous  - louis vuitton outlet
    Want to become more charming and faddish? Go to visit louis vuitton outlet webpage and select the most suitable products for yourself.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-02 03:42:14 Anonymous  - christian louboutin uk
    Yesterday, I saw an advertisement of lady's handbags on christian Outlets Online. I was obsessed by the unique decorative pattern and special appearance of christian louboutin uk.You can discover all types of style and design bags on christian louboutin, including the hot selling christianpurses and christianwallets. The christianwallets are popular among the designer luxury, simply due to their craftsmanship is extremely good as well as the price is reasonable to you.Among those goods, I like the christian louboutin sale most; they are cheap and have a superior quality. I feel fashionable when I take one with me.You'll bask in the personalized service provided by General Manager Patrick Floch and Sommelier Patrick Peterson. christian louboutin uk sale has been awarded the highest rating of four stars by both the Detroit News & the Detroit Free Press, as well as the Wine Spectator's coveted 'Best of' Award of Excellence.
    ReplyQuote
  • |2011-12-20 05:58:26 cheap wedding dresses  - cheap wedding dresses
    I know you probably get a lot of comments like this cheap wedding dresses, but just wanted to let you know that I really appreciate the work you have put into the blog. I was wondering if I could put a link on my blog because I am sure my followers would love to read it wedding party dresses. Let me know.
    ReplyQuote
Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
 
Facebook MySpace Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Google Bookmarks RSS Feed 
Slot Machines Coupon Redeem Vegas Free Money Casino No Deposit Play Texas Tea Slots Online Strip Slot Games Alicia Slot Machine Double Diamond Slot Online El San Juan Hotel Y Casino Pegasus Casino Slot Machine Game Free Play Casinos No Deposit Play Bingo Online For Free Casino System Hack Bingo Game Sale Best Casino Free Casino Games Without Downloading Caesars Palace Hotel And Casino No Deposit Required Casino Northern Lights Casino Carter Wi Deposit Min Online Casino Video Poker Moneygames Revell Slot Car Track No Deposit Casino Blog Platinum Casino No Deposit Free Download Casino Island Game Free Off Line Casino Games Cirrus Free Chip New Orleans Casino In Las Vegas Microgaming Free Spins Free Virtual Slot Machines Ffree CasinoSdown Load Casino Real Play Igt Online Slots Free Casino Texas Tea Free Alantis Freeslotmachinegames.Org Casino Birthday Card Free Machine Double Diamond Lobstermania Free Online Slots Casino Igt Vegas Slot Machines To Play Online Gold Coast Casino Reviews No Deposit Poker Coupon Code Pala Casino Coupons Bonus Free No Deposit Las Vegas Coupons Cod Cirrus Bet Royal Coupons And Codes Play Blackjack Online Links Wild Vegas Casino No Deposit Free Cleopatra Slot Game Free Online Cleopatra And United States Free Sighnup Cash Online Casinos Casinos Sltos Gratis Online Casinos No Deposit Bonuses Vegas Strip No Deposit Bonus Code Poker Rule Books Clip Art Slot Machine Casinos That Accept 10 Cleopatra.Slot.Machine