Elder of Ziyon continues his analysis of the GFFM Report's flaws. We include this one in "The Goldstone Standard" because although it might be in "Human Shields," the major topic it illustrates is the tortured and deeply unfair logic that the Mission applied to the evide
The Goldstone Report has a section about the booby-trapping of Palestinian Arab houses by Hamas.
If Hamas booby-trapped houses in civilian neighborhoods, that would violate the principle of distinction, which is a major claim that Goldstone accuses Israel of routinely failing to distinguish between civilians and combatants during the operation. It would mean that Hamas disregarded the lives of its own people to at least the same extent that the report claims the IDF forces did.
Goldstone looks at the evidence, and starts off with a logically bizarre paragraph:
461. In chapter XIV the Mission will report on different incidents in which witnesses have described the circumstances in which they had been used by the Israeli armed forces during house searches and forced at gunpoint to enter houses ahead of the Israeli soldiers. These witnesses testified that they had been used in this way to enter several houses. None of them encountered a booby trap or other improvised explosive devices during the house searches. The Mission is also mindful of other incidents it has investigated that involved entry into civilian houses by Israeli soldiers in different areas in Gaza. None of these incidents showed the use of booby traps.
Goldstone begins his analysis of whether Hamas booby-trapped houses and civilian areas by saying that none of its eyewitnesses, who were handpicked by the Commission to prove the worst allegations of Israeli abuses, verified that they saw any Hamas booby-traps - while they were detailing highly suspect testimony that Israel used these witnesses as human shields.
Besides the fact that these people were not chosen to investigate booby-trap claims, Goldstone is implying that since they didn't see the booby traps, there is no direct evidence that such traps existed. One does not have to be a military expert to realize that if Hamas did booby trap homes, they would not have wired up every house in every neighborhood; rather they would only choose a sample of homes that they would try to lure IDF soldiers into. Saying that supposed witnesses did not see any booby traps is, literally, meaningless as proof one way or the other.
In addition, it also illustrates a case in which Goldstone did not set out to investigate Hamas war crimes, and only reported on things that the commission found out about while they were investigating alleged Israeli crimes.
Goldstone then allows that there were reports of booby-traps:
462. The Mission, however, recalls the allegations levelled in the reports that it has reviewed. The Government of Israel alleges that Hamas planted booby traps in “homes, roads, schools and even entire neighbourhoodsâ€. It adds, “in essence, the Hamas strategy was to transform the urban areas of the Gaza Strip into a massive death trap for IDF forces, in gross disregard for the safety of the civilian population.â€317
The Mission notes that the existence of booby-trapped houses is mentioned in testimonies of Israeli soldiers collected by Breaking the Silence. One soldier recounts witnessing the detonation of a powerful explosion inside a house as a bulldozer approached it. A second soldier stated “many explosive charges were found, they also blew up, no one was hurt. Tank Corps or Corps of Engineers units blew them up. Usually they did not explode because most of the ones we found were wired and had to be detonated, but whoever was supposed to detonate them had run off. It was live, however, ready…â€.318
Also the reports published by Palestinian armed groups, on which the submission to the Mission on the tactics of Palestinian combatants by the Jerusalem Centre for Public Affairs is based, suggest that booby-trapped civilian houses were a frequently used tactic.319 According to the Israeli Government, “because roads and buildings were often mined, IDF forces had to target them to protect themselvesâ€.320
So after writing an initial paragraph whose only purpose is to cast doubt on any claims of Hamas booby traps, Goldstone briefly lists some damning evidence that such devices did exist. The Breaking the Silence testimonies, which Goldstone accepts uncritically when it slams the IDF, is quoted as having "mentioned" seeing booby traps, and terrorist websites themselves bragged about using such tactics. By any reasonable standard, this would appear to be real proof, not simply "allegations." Yet Goldstone places it after a paragraph that starts off the discussion by casting doubt that such devices existed and clearly downplays all of this evidence by lumping it all together into a single paragraph.
His final paragraph on the topic shows the incontrovertible  bias that the Commission had:
463. While, in the light of the above reports, the Mission does not discount the use of booby traps by the Palestinian armed groups, it has no basis to conclude that civilian lives were put at risk, as none of the reports record the presence of civilians in or near the houses in which booby traps are alleged to have been set.
Again, if Hamas placed live bombs in civilian areas, they are violating international law. Yet this report soft-pedals this war crime by saying that there is no evidence that any civilians were nearby - in civilian neighborhoods! Goldstone seems to be adding a new caveat to the Geneva Conventions - saying that civilian objects can be used by terrorists if there is no evidence that any civilians are there at the time they are planted. Perhaps Goldstone did not envision the civilians ever returning to their houses and opening their own front doors. This is mind-boggling.
While Israel is castigated by Goldstone for not being specific enough in dropping hundreds of thousands of flyers warning civilians to leave areas before they bombed. Hamas booby traps buildings in these same areas, and does not warn residents to leave at all - yet their actions are not condemned at all!
If using civilian areas as a base of attack in order to protect the attackers is illegal under international law, shouldn't the purposeful use of civilian objects themselves as weapons (something that Geneva didn't seem to imagine) be considered even worse?
This pseudo-legal stretching to absolve Hamas of responsibility for booby traps is not even the most egregious problem. These three paragraphs constitute the entirety of Goldstone's investigation into this topic. Yet Goldstone ignored the most obvious evidence of Hamas' use of booby traps.
One is the well-known video of the booby-trapped zoo and school in Gaza that the IDF discovered:
Adobe Flash Player not installed or older than 9.0.115!
Another is this map, captured by the IDF, that showed the placement of booby traps in the Al-Atatra neighborhood: The map shows placement of bombs in houses and near gas stations.
Â
In addition, here is a photograph (from a JCPA PowerPoint) of a booby trap in a house:
Â
Both the video and the map were well publicized during Cast Lead, and it is not possible that the Commission would have been unaware of this evidence.
In short, this short section on booby-traps shows Goldstone's bias against Israel, his bias towards Hamas, his playing fast and loose with the law, and his purposeful ignoring of evidence that goes against his apparently pre-formed conclusions.
|2010-12-09 02:11:49
moncler jackets
- moncler jackets men
Moncler jackets on sale sports apparel company established in 1952 Rome, Texas Lemon village in the French Alps. In an unprecedented social shop moncler sale is the inventor of the famous hot, very light, ideal for all winter ski clothes simple colors. Moncler jackets for cheap and comfortable port of French fashion is not so outdated. We believe moncler jacket Store now offers products for every season moncler online scale. It is not only beneficial to high-quality but cheaper price compared to other providers of Moncler Coat
Xiaolaba In one's life, the person is in learning in the growth of the growing learning in ear headphones, copy is like is a cyclical definition. Facing different setbacks trouble bose headphones, always a personal face, which afraid to flee or strong learn to face it alone sennheiser headphones , that is life difficult to avoid "independent". The dilemma of digestion, often than books in the study best headphones . Experienced the frustration of exercise, can learn life "truth", namely "wisdom" in ear earphones. The life of every choice is actually "a door, the door key has been mastered" in their hands monster headphones. But many was beside the scenery entice or confuse monster beats headphones, while tyndareus late open time, often in late time, man ting, mind will struggle among wandering in right and wrong. Have a kind of knowledge is called "philosophy" best in ear headphones, with the help of it, we can clear open which a doo...
Fashion changes every second, moncler outlet made a lot of media play in disseminating people's lifestyle, an important role. You can see the trend change, but the moncler store jacket is stylish. We see a large and complex fashion moncler clothing jackets. If a large number of companies are the most popular and moncler online shop stylish jacket in the world. This brand is growing rapidly in popularity over the years, moncler 2010 and a high level of market success. Quality and design a way to give your people love Moncler clothing. discount moncler womens is made of high fashion and durable fabric. In this way, men and women have increased buy moncler women confidence in the brand jacket their interest is to keep your eye on the purchase. But before you shut down discount moncler men Moncler Everest shopping unnecessary work, you must first understand its buy moncler mens coat, how to lose weight and your body, how to use their skills to get the full experience, all skiing. If you...
There’s something important about designer tiesthis piece of clothing: no man’s wardrobe can survive burberry tie sale without ties. It’s the so-called centerpiece of a gentleman’s Armani Tie salecollection of clothes. Men’s ties can reasonably increase cheap Chanel Tiethe status in the society as well as decrease it. Fashion trends of new era neckties can fully represent the personality of a wearer andGucci Tie salehis ability to keep up with a chosen bluff image.
The feature people are looking for while choosing Hugo Boss Tie sale neckties today is its general quality.cheap Louis Vuitton TieMens ties trends 2011 are no exception. One of the most common cheap Paul Smith Tiedelusions is that the quality necktie should be of alloyed silk onlyPaul Smith Tie sale, without any patterns. But anyone used to such aberrations can easily overcome this statement.
Speaking of polyester ties, by all means they should be avoided Louis Vuitton Tie because of their absence of form and thecheap ...
Its my great pleasure to visit our website and to enjoy your awesome topics on baseball caps for sale, I appriciate that a lot. I see that you paid much attention for those topics on mens leather belts,
|2011-10-21 01:20:17
Hermes sale
- Hermes sale
These hermes handbags are mostly worn to express your thoughts and personality. For instance, a hermes birkin is worn by someone who plays or likes to play violin. Similarly a hermes kelly is worn by someone who dreams of winning the same. If not, then you can get replica hermes handbags engraved in the shape of your initials. So, hermes birkin purse are more than just an accessory to enhance your style. Buying hermes replica handbags can often be confusing. Browse through our buying hermes bags tips to get an insight into buying the right one. Among the most important hermes birkin handbags buying tips are - always buy only from a reputed store and read thoroughly through the warranty policy. One of the most important hermes sale buying tips when it comes to gemstones, is to beware of imitations in plastic and glass. The synthetically manufactured christian louboutin shoes are less expensive than naturally mined stones. When it comes to christian louboutin sale, since natural pearl...
|2011-10-21 02:15:28
nike sb shoes
I agree with your Blog and I will be back to check it more in the future so please keep up your work. You may be interesting in nike sb shoes.Thanks for your sharing.belstaff jackets uk
Hey, I am really feel grateful to you for sharing such a great idea about cheap burberry online for me. Wonderful, I also share you with a great opportunity,maybe you need them. Welcome to cheap Gucci sale
Thanks for this article!What in circumstance you are preparing a holiday to some tropical
Coach Purses as well as you just have positively practically nothing to found
on within your feet Air Jordan Shoes? instructor sandals are just that which
you call up for supplied which they are extremely elaborate with sparkling variations and bold
Cheap UGG Boots , that come going to be fabulous for just about any sunny
Tiffany & Co. Positively you can usually choose
Coach Outlet Store to found near to the undemanding coloring devoid of any
MBT Sneakers, but why wouldn’t you call up for to critically have some
enjoyment with Prada Bags more with one another with your ft
at any time you go apart and Tiffany Jewelry the beach?But
UGG Boots Sale you do not call up for to only have your ft stepped in to some
Cheap Jordans coloring this season; you may possibly preserve the
MBT Shoes glimpse just a tiny a whole fantastic offer a wonderful offer ...